9 votes

"Trollerators" aka moderators need moderation

Not a complete answer but to touch on some of your points: More spam than they prevent: Many of the Commoderators spend 10 seconds moderating/closing a question that could be edited and answered ...
  • 2,917
9 votes
Accepted

Should we treat questions about assignment in a different way?

Personally & as a teacher, I think it we should adopt the SO stance on homework. There's nothing unique to game development that warrants altering their protocol. Here's my summary of the SO ...
  • 9,334
4 votes

Should this very old question with many upvotes as well as upvoted answers be closed as "too broad"?

Also, it did get edited recently, yet the editor fails to even correct a dead link where the OP posts a link to their discovered answer. Fortunately, you were there to save the day! Jokes aside, ...
  • 15.8k
4 votes

What to do with links / imagery with sexual content?

Is it appropriate to post imagery of sexual content if the question could call for it? No, it is even less appropriate than posting links since everyone that sees the question / answer will ...
  • 7,680
3 votes

What to do with links / imagery with sexual content?

Is it appropriate to link to pornographic sites such as the one mentioned above? Yes. It is appropriate to post links to pornographic sites as long as they are relevant and they are clearly ...
  • 7,680
3 votes

Would GDSE benefit from an official "back it up" policy?

A strict "back it up" policy is hard on new users who end up running into the 2 link limit for <10 rep users on their first question or answer. On Skeptics Stack Exchange, where much of the value ...
1 vote

Should this very old question with many upvotes as well as upvoted answers be closed as "too broad"?

I'll try to address your other concern: Fine question, lots of interest, but closed after 8 years as "too broad". Is that the right action? and I think the moderator opinion means very little ...
  • 15.8k

Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible