If I have a question to which the answers lead to realizations that dramatically change the scope or context of the question; should I edit the question to rephrase or expand it; or should I ask a new question in reference to the old one, incorporating references to the answers and original question?

Edit: Or, as an alternative, answer my own question.


1 Answer 1


You should always post a new question if you have a new question - otherwise the existing answers are tangential at best and nonsense at worst.

If you're giving up on the question because you realized it was a bad question, just delete it.

If you're giving up on the question because you found the answer and it led to a new question, answer it if you think the answer might be useful to someone else. I would err on the side of deleting rather than answering your own question - if the answers would be useful to someone else, someone else will probably ask it again, and you'll know more to answer it when they do.


You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .