Is “general feedback on game” on-topic?

Question

I am working on an Android game scenario inspired by Moon Patrol. I am making progress and I don't have any very specific problem. I have posted the code for code review https://codereview.stackexchange.com/questions/196658/improved-android-game-inspired-by-moon-patrol

The beta version is available for beta test from https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=dev.android.buggy

I want feedback but I don't know what to ask. Should I not ask because I don't really have a technical problem, I just want feedback in general from some specialist?

Answer 1

Generally, open-ended "feedback" on just about anything -- game ideas, actual game products, intended mechanical or technical designs -- falls under either the category of "primarily opinion based" or the category of "too broad" and is thus off-topic here.

Questions that propose "this is how I'm going to solve , is this good/bad/any ideas?" fall into this category, but are generally easier to edit into something on-topic by rephrasing them as "how do I solve " and encouraging the asker to re-post their intended solution as an answer, submitting it to feedback and votes.

It doesn't seem possible to do this in a general way with "what do you think of my game" questions, so I think you're better off asking them elsewhere (either on SE as noted in some comments, or on another site altogether like GDNet.