up vote 0 down vote favorite

I'm aware of this question in Meta: Do we need tags for 'rectangle', 'circle', 'triangle', 'hexagon' and 'shape'?, and as a hex grid nut I think the 'hexagon' tag is a special case.

Having said that, I've found a list of questions related to hexagons (as in "hex grids") that are missing the 'hexagon' tag:

I'm not advocating for a massive serial retag, as I know (and I've felt in other SE sites) how disruptive those massive retaggings are, but hopefully something slower and calmer could be done about it.

It would be nice to have 'hexagon', 'hexes' and 'hexgrid' search results under the same tag.

After all, this SE may be the best online resource about hex grids, bar the excellent guide at Red Blob Games.

share
up vote 3 down vote accepted

I still feel that hexagon is too generic as a tag.

You have a point that all these questions are logically grouped under the concept of a hexagonal grid, however, so I don't immediately see anything wrong with a tag for or similar (the grid being the important part).

share
  • I think 'hexagon' is not that bad as a compromise, because the calculations involving a hex grid are related to the specific geometric properties of the hexagon. 'hexagonal-grid' may be better though. Anyways, my post was more about (my perceived) need to add a 'hexagon' (or 'hexagonal-grid') tag to that list of questions. Maybe I should edit the question to clarify? – Rodia May 5 at 14:10
  • 2
    I think it's clear enough you're proposing adding a tag to those questions, and that's fine. I just don't think "hexagon" is a good candidate. The consensus is already to blacklist it (so by adding it, you'd just be making more work to undo it and re-apply something more appropriate); in general we have far too many tags here that are pointlessly broad, making them useless. More concept- or technique-specific tags would be better, which is why I think some tag that includes the grid aspect in the name would be better. – Josh♦ May 5 at 14:22
  • 1
    I just went ahead and made hexagonal-grid, so it should be possible to apply that to the appropriate questions in the list now. – Josh♦ May 5 at 14:44
  • I'm the first follower of hexagonal-grid, yes! – Rodia May 5 at 14:53
  • Shoud we remove the tag 'grid' from questions tagged, or to be tagged, with 'hexagonal-grid'? An example: Finding all hexagonal grid coordinates inside cover arc. – Rodia May 7 at 20:50
  • 1
    @Rodia In general, probably, as it's likely redundant (unless perhaps the question is also about conventional grids as the grid tag covers). – Josh♦ May 7 at 21:09
  • All the hexagon tagged questions have been moved to hexagonal-grid now, except for this one (edit was rejected by the poster), and two others that are not related to hex grids but genuinely to hexagons. May need a mod to edit these three questions and burninate hexagon once and for all. – Rodia Jul 6 at 13:00
up vote 1 down vote

Unless I'm missing something, why can't you just do an edit a day (or whatever pace you feel would be non-disruptive) in which you apply the tag to a question from your hit list?

Granted, at the moment, your edits would need to get approval, but since you don't want a fast disruptive process, this shouldn't be a problem. I think it also grants you a bit of rep in the process. Seems win-win to me.

That being said, please make sure that hexs are a core part of the question when tagging. For instance, the last question (White dots artifacts when applying borders to hex tiled geometry) seems borderline - to me, that problem isn't about hexes per say, but issues with aliasing & diagonal lines. Since it is likely that others implementing hex grids might run into similar problems, it's probably okay to use the hex tag there, but hopefully you get the idea - a problem can utilize concept X without necessarily being about concept X.

share
  • That was my first idea, I edited today Recognizing a hexagonal clickbox, but got a declined review, which I somehow understand. Good catch about last question, I had my doubts too, but I think ultimately it's hex grid related. I totally left outside the list questions mentioning hexagons as a trivial part, and questions about that Super Hexagon game :) – Rodia May 5 at 14:39

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .