A user recently asked where they could download the Havok Physics engine. I was under the impression that "where can I download X?" questions were considered off-topic, and flagged it as such.

However, since then, two answers have appeared. One of them is by one of our moderators. Are "where can I download X?" questions off-topic? Alternatively, should they be?


2 Answers 2


No, we shouldn't permit "where do I download X" questions. But if it's possible to edit those questions to turn them into something other than a simple link request, we should try to salvage them that way.


Questions asking us for a download source shpuld be considered off-topic, but on a case-by-case analysis, they may still be fairly salveageable.

Regardless of policy, I see some issues with these sort of questions.

The user is asking for a web link

If we assume the download is accessible, it seems to me like good answers would follow the following format:

You can download X from the (X/Company Y) website. Just follow this link for the download page.

It seems as if it would be rather difficult to post a good answer, with out providing the link. This creates a Catch-22; it can not be considered a good answer if it does not hold with out the link. We have a very strict policy with this, to prevent good answers becoming bad answers due to link rot.

To a minor extent, the user is asking for recommendation

We consider software and technology recommendation questions off-topic. I would only loosely group these questions in with "where can I download X?", but ultimately, the user is asking us to recommend a specific website to provide the appropriate technology.

One might argue that different answers may also lead to different 'preferred versions'. While this is an issue I can see, I am not sure it is really a big one.

Salvage versus Close

It is entirely possible that we could edit these questions to be on-topic, and still draw the response the user is looking for.

Why is X no longer accessible?

Sometimes, the root of the question comes from confusion, when a previously accessible piece of software becomes impossible to find.

In the example, the user likely1 googled "Havok" and found that although there is a lot of reference to a shareware version, there are no links on the official page.

As answers have since pointed out, a semi-recent acquisition resulted in the shareware version being discontinued. Bummer.

I see no reason we can not allow "Why can't I access X anymore?" questions, in the rare situation where this is the actual case. I actually found the answers, in this case, very helpful.

Is X available to the public?

When it comes down to a complete lack of being able to find reference to a download, I see no reason why the user can not ask if there is a download.

This might highlight the actual problem, as there was with the example question. A good answer would still provide links to the download, if valid, while still directly answering the question in text format. Win, win.

1 Assuming, in good faith, that the user did try to find the download, themselves, before posting.


You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .